Skip to: Navigation | Content | Footer


Unreliable sources

James Evelegh's editorial from today's edition of InPubWeekly.

James Evelegh

Posted on: 06 September 2018


As editorial budgets shrivel, editors look for efficiencies: headcounts are cut, contributor fees slashed, and cheaper ways of filling up pages sought.

One of the cheapest sources is the online comments section below celebrity articles and posts; an endless supply of completely free content, never mind the fact that most comments fall into two camps: the gushings of the uberfans or the eye-popping, does-your-mother-know-you-write-this-kind-of-stuff offerings of the seriously warped.

Find a premise (eg a celeb is endlessly talking about herself and fans are sick of it), trawl through the online comments and, hey presto, you have a DPS feature for virtually nothing. What’s more, you can give the job to the intern.

In the short term, you’ve succeeded in getting an issue out on a shoestring, but at what cost to your brand?

If magazines simply regurgitate online comments, what extra value do they bring? Why buy the mag, when you can read the comments yourself online for free? Most of the comments on celebrity sites are not worth repeating – the musings of fans or haters.

Now magazine got burnt this week when it ran a comments-based piece on Stacey Solomon, who bit back, calling it “the meanest thing I’ve ever seen” prompting an apology from the publishers.

The thing is that the issues being discussed in the offending article were completely legit territory for a celeb mag: body image, body hair, and bringing up kids. There are interesting things that could have been said by an experienced columnist or journalist, which would have made it a much better read and given Ms Solomon less room for complaint.

Yes, it would have cost slightly more to put together, but it would have been intelligent and unique content that would have given purchasers of Now magazine a reason to buy it again.

About James Evelegh
(Details last updated: 21 March 2018)

James Evelegh is the editor of InPublishing. Previous roles have included circulation consultant, group circulation manager at Centaur Media and circulation manager at DMG Trinity.

Tel: 01322 865 984

Email: Send a message to this author


Twitter: @InPublishing

Coming soon - new commenting facility.

Most read on InPublishing

These are the most read stories on the InPublishing website over the last 14 days, in order from the top.


BSME Awards - shortlist

Posted on: 12 October 2018

Stylist launch new TV panel show

Posted on: 15 October 2018

Johnston Press up for sale

Posted on: 12 October 2018

Directorship changes at Future

Posted on: 16 October 2018

CIM appoints LID Publishing

Posted on: 9 October 2018

Claverley acquires Cubiquity

Posted on: 10 October 2018

Vogue appointments

Posted on: 17 October 2018


Room for growth

Ciar Byrne
Posted on: 25 September 2018

Child’s play

Meg Carter
Posted on: 25 September 2018

From copy boy to editor

Steve Dyson
Posted on: 25 September 2018

History lessons

James Evelegh
Posted on: 25 September 2018

Buggy brilliant

James Evelegh
Posted on: 11 October 2018

Health & fitness magazines

Alan Geere
Posted on: 25 September 2018

The Leisure Principle

Tim Robinson
Posted on: 25 September 2018

Mind the HIPPO

James Evelegh
Posted on: 3 October 2018

Off The Page

David Hepworth
Posted on: 25 September 2018

Fighting the good fight

Ray Snoddy
Posted on: 25 September 2018

This list is based on data from Google Analytics, and is refreshed every 24 hours. (Last updated: 20/10/2018 05:58)

Editor's Pick of Recent News Stories

Posted on: 19 October 2018
Posted on: 17 October 2018
Posted on: 15 October 2018
Posted on: 12 October 2018
Posted on: 11 October 2018

Find out more about

InPub Weekly: Sign-up

Click here to sign up for our free weekly email newsletter:

Sign up now!

Magazine registration

Publishing Partners Guide

Guide to paid-content